I’ve Been a Rabbi Fighting Racial Injustice for Decades. But I Have Not Done Enough.


By Rabbi Sid Schwarz
David Axelrod, a former top aide to President Barack Obama often credited with masterminding his two successful campaigns for the presidency, recently published a column in The Washington Post that hit me between the eyes and sat heavily on my heart.

Axelrod and I are about the same age. He was too young to have been active in the civil rights movement of the 1960s, but he was deeply affected by the story and eager to believe the myth that the movement, headed by Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., solved the problem of racial injustice in America.

Axelrod worked for Mayor Harold Washington, a Black public official who broke Richard Daley’s 20-plus year hold on the mayor’s office in Chicago. As a journalist in the early 1980s, Axelrod wrote about unequal justice and police brutality in America.

But he did not have Black friends with whom he was close enough to ask and understand their life experience.

He wrote in the Post: “I thought I understood. Now I realize I did not. Not well enough. Not in the visceral way that comes when you truly imagine yourself in someone else’s shoes.”

Me too. I could easily trot out my activist resume and cite all the ways I have engaged in the issue of racial justice over the past 40-plus years. But I am left feeling ashamed on two levels: ashamed for the way that the richest country in the world has refused to confront its systemic racism, and ashamed of the fact that, like Axelrod, even as I became aware of how America has stacked the deck against Black Americans, it has never been my top priority.

Like many other Jews, I have lobbied my elected representatives on the issues of Holocaust awareness, fighting anti-Semitism and liberating Soviet Jewry. I urged them to support Israel.

But I did not cash in my political capital for Black Americans. And of that, I am ashamed.
For the past couple of years, I was part of an Interfaith Task Force on Racism. We held forums throughout the county that brought together citizens of all backgrounds to speak about combating bigotry and racism.

Nobody came to these forums with white supremacist bumper stickers or Confederate flags.

Everyone I met in these workshops seemed well-intentioned and saw themselves as “the good guys” on this issue.

Until, of course, the issue of white privilege came up. That is when all these well-intentioned white folks got very defensive.

Most white people, including myself, are not prepared to realize how much they are part of a system that keeps them in a position of privilege at the expense of people of color.

Even more importantly, while saying all the right things in polite company — especially in carefully constructed multifaith and multiracial dialogue settings — most white people are not prepared to surrender any of the privileges that they enjoy in order to remedy centuries of discrimination against people of color. Many Jews fall into this very same pattern of behavior.

We say we want to end racism, but we don’t want a Black family to move into our neighborhood.

We say we want to end racism, but we won’t support busing to desegregate our schools.
We say we want to end racism, but we won’t support affirmative action if it denies our son or daughter a slot at a prestigious college or professional school.

We say we want to end racism, but we are not prepared to be true allies until Black organizations pass every ideological test we create on support for Israel.

We say we want to end racism, but we can’t bring ourselves to sign on to critiques of over-policing because the police are protecting our synagogues and they rarely, if ever, harass or kill white Jews without due process, as happens routinely to Black Americans.

Jews, like most white people, have a host of reasons to deflect responsibility for America’s original sin of racism. I have heard dozens of arguments from white people denying that the privileges that they enjoy contribute to the oppression of Black and brown people.

In the end, I can boil all the arguments from a shelf full of books on white privilege down to a poster that I saw at a Black Lives Matter rally I recently attended: “Privilege is when you think something is not a problem because it is not a problem for you.”

Spend some time talking to Black people about the obstacles they face daily to access good schools, healthy food, adequate health care, access to mass transit, equal treatment in our criminal justice system, and it is likely you will feel ashamed of the privileges that you enjoy and that are not available to people of color.

Contemplate the statistic that in the year 2020, the net wealth of an average Black family is only 10% of the wealth of an average white family in America. Read the history of redlining and how Blacks were denied the benefits of the GI Bill after World War II, and you will understand how Black poverty is a consequence of state-sanctioned policy. Or put yourself in the shoes of Black children who are more likely to see police as people who will harm them than as people who are there to protect them.

In a 1972 essay arguing against clerical apathy on issues of foreign policy, Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel said, “Morally speaking, there is no limit to the concern one must feel for the suffering of human beings, that indifference to evil is worse than evil itself, that in a free society, some are guilty, but all are responsible.”

Jews need to take responsibility for the perpetuation of racism in America. We have averted our eyes to the suffering of Black Americans for generations. It is time to face the hard truth, become true allies and marshal all of our considerable political capital to remedy an injustice that has been allowed to exist for far too long.

Rabbi Sid Schwarz is a senior fellow at Hazon and the founding rabbi of Adat Shalom Reconstructionist Congregation in Bethesda, Maryland. He is the author of several books including “Judaism and Justice: The Jewish Passion to Repair the World.” This piece first appeared on JTA.org.


  1. Rabbi, what is your answer to the alarming growth of black anti-Semitism and hatred of Israel? The poisonous work of Linda Sarsour, Rashida Tliab, Ilhan Omar, their mentor, Louis Farrakhan, and now AOC, is creating a threatening and dangerous environment for American Jews, and coopting BLM as an antisemetic force of intimidation. If I am not for myself…

  2. I was born and raised in South Phila. My parents were Jewish immigrants, and I am first generation American. I read with interest several articles that left me troubled and confused. What we are seeing now is not about racism (that is the guise) but about a Marxist overthrow of our government and our freedom.
    I worked in the 60’s for a Jewish couple running a credit company. My co-worker was African American and single parent with a child. She was from N. Carolina and followed the father to Phila. The employer and his wife treated me like royalty, but I started to observe how they treated this young lady. It got to a point where discrimination against her was so obvious, I would sit at the dinner table with my parents and start crying. To make a long story short I was fired as a trouble maker because I threatened to report them to the NAACP. At least, possibly out of fear, they treated Shirley better after I was fired.
    I moved with my husband to New Mexico where he pursued his law degree and later became a District Court Judge, and received my degree as an RN in 1978. In 1985, I went to Ethiopia to work as part of a medical relief team during the famine. Due to my exposure to antisemitism growing up, I felt a closeness to those of color and their harsh treatment as well. In Ethiopia, I sadly saw the mistreatment of the people there by Ethiopian comrades. The government (military coup) were feasting at banquets while those in our camps were suffering the effects of the starvation and disease. Our Ethiopian physician who wanted to live in the USA more than anything, didn’t ask for himself. He asked if I would sponsor his sister. I called my husband and asked if we could and he said “yes.” No questions about how we would do it, or what our responsibility would be because he is just that way. It took us three years to bring her to this country and we had to PLEDGE that she would never fall under government subsidizing. We would pay everything (medical, food, clothing, etc.) which we gladly did. She was age 20 and could speak a little English. That started her education, and we paid for her college up through her Bachelors in Nursing. She worked hard and paid for her Nurse Practitioner License. She was naturalized a citizen. Her Ethiopian boyfriend had escaped to Australia and then came to the USA. They are married and have three children. She resides outside of Chicago and is now had been supervisor of three floors at two hospitals. She is now manager of a clinic working with brain injured patients. We are godparents to her eldest son. I also got her brother, our Ethiopian doctor, political asylum, and he is a hospitalist married to an Ethiopian Pediatrician in Maryland, living the American dream.
    I am now a CEO of a non profit working with children and youth, as well as those incarcerated teaching social and emotional learning skills. More than 80 % of the children in our program are Hispanic and I just love them. So much promise and so much potential.
    I tell you this because I am not a racist or some of white privilege. I was a post WWII children exposed to the Nazi newsreels. Do you remember those? I also had my share of antisemitism. With all that said, I am 100% against what I see going on right now in Phila and in all other States that are allowing these riots and looting to take place. George Floyd’s tragic situation has turned into a Marxist movement that has nothing to do with the death of this young man nor racism. Where are the Rabbi Schwartz outcries against the black on black murders that take place in Chicago murdering innocent children and adults. What about those killed by these anarchists posing as protesters. Who is helping to remedy the small business owners, many blacks as well as other minorities, who livelihoods were destroyed. Shame on all of you for not protesting the unjustice and lawlessness taking place in your cities and states.
    George Soros, whose disgusting comment in a video about what he did to his own Jewish people in Hungary was “If I didn’t do it someone else would have” has no outcry by the Jewish community, is funding these radicals including Atntifa. Many other other billionaires who see socialism as acceptable alternative are also involved. Leaders and corporations are pandering to this mob. My head aches when I think of how complacent the Jews in Germany and Europe that Germany would never allow such unrest and hatred to ensue. Well we are seeing it now and those of you who don’t recognize this for what it is will bring down the rest of the country. I doubt you will even print this.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here