By Sophia Rodney
I am a proud Jew, a proud American, a proud supporter of Israel and a Democrat too. But there are two main reasons why I am struggling to reconcile my identity as a supporter of Israel and a Democrat.
First, I believe President Joe Biden’s plans to rejoin the Iran nuclear deal poses an enormous threat to the safety and even existence of Israel.
Second, I believe the Democratic congresswomen who are part of “The Squad” are contributing to a heightened climate of hatred of Israel and Jews.
Let’s discuss the Iran deal.
During former President Barack Obama’s first term in office, Iran had allegedly been developing a nuclear program. So, various countries, including the United States, imposed crippling economic sanctions on the country. In 2015, Iran agreed to a deal that lifted these sanctions. This was the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action, now informally known as the Iran nuclear deal.
The deal was a disaster for three main reasons: Iran did not comply and lied about it, Iran used its new access to the formerly frozen assets to increase its ballistic missile program, which now poses a threat to Israel, and Iran used these assets to also fund Israel-hating proxy militant groups across the Middle East.
In terms of Iran’s lack of compliance, in 2018, Netanyahu announced, according to the Daily Mail, that Israel’s intelligence services had documents that proved Iran secretly continued developing a nuclear program that violated the treaty.
In terms of how Iran used its new access to the once frozen assets, according to the Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies, Iran used deal-acquired finances to strengthen its ballistic missile program. Also, in March of 2016, Iran tested ballistic missiles with the words “Israel must be wiped out” on them, as CBS News reported. So, Americans are naive to think Iran would never use its new ballistic missile power to attack Israel.
In terms of how Iran used funding from the deal to strengthen proxy groups that seek to destroy Israel, Nathan Sales, the former U.S. State Department’s top counter-terrorism official, averred in early 2020 that Iran gives Hezbollah $700 million and Hamas $100 million annually. These are funds that would be much harder to provide if the Iran nuclear deal had not made Iran so much wealthier.
Biden is reportedly going to settle for some version of this extremely flawed deal again.
Then there’s “The Squad,” the nickname applied to four female Democrat members of Congress, including Rashida Tlaib, Ilhan Omar and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.
When Biden announced his nominee for Secretary of State, Antony Blinken, who happens to be Jewish, Tlaib tweeted, “So long as he doesn’t suppress my First Amendment right to speak out against Netanyahu’s racist and inhumane policies. The Palestinian people deserve equality and justice.”
So Biden nominates a Jew to his cabinet and Tlaib automatically assumes he wants to suppress her right to speak out … because he is Jewish? This is anti-Semitism.
In March of 2019, Omar said at a public forum, “I want to talk about the political influence in this country that says it is OK for people to push for allegiance to a foreign country,” while speaking about the US-Israel relationship.
Jonathan Greenblatt, the CEO of the Anti-Defamation League, explained why Omar’s remarks were anti-Semitic: “Accusing Jews of having allegiance to a foreign government has long been a vile anti-Semitic slur used to harass, marginalize, and persecute the Jewish people for centuries.”
Last but not least, we have Ocasio-Cortez, who is affiliated with Democratic Socialists of America, which has voted to adopt the anti-Israel boycott, divestment and sanctions movement. BDS is anti-Semitic for many reasons, as CAMERA has outlined. But, for starters, a South African BDS leader alleged in March 2020 that COVID-19-related materials were not printed in Arabic, which was false. This is blatant anti-Semitism.
How can I, a Jewish person who believes in the Jewish right to self-determination, associate myself with these people? When my political party starts spreading messages against the Jewish right to self-determination, a basic human right, and endorses movements that spread blood libels about my people, then I begin to feel ostracized and scared.
I am a student at the University of Pennsylvania. When I pitched this op-ed topic to my classmates and explained that I fear these congresswomen and their potential abilities to push the Democratic Party to hate Israel even more, one classmate told me to “be careful because my argument sounds Trumpian.”
These congresswomen have normalized hating Israel and Jews so much so that I am now considered a “Trumpian,” and completely ostracized by my peers, for expressing my concerns for Israel and the anti-Semitic rhetoric these women are spreading.
I am not a “Trumpian.” I am a proud Zionist Jew who feels like my party, the Democratic Party, has taken a turn for the worse.
Sophia Rodney is a student at the University of Pennsylvania.
I strongly agree with your positions. The fact that your peers turned on you so quickly is proof that the anti-Israel and anti-semite rhetoric is having it’s decided affect.
Stand by your guns. We must continue to expose these issues and fight against them with the light of the truth.
Maybe it’s time for a new political party.
Welcome to the world and to haven woken up to the reality of today’s Democrat party.
You can readily see where the democrat party under Biden’s leadership is headed. It is obviously against Jews, against Israel and from the standpoint of a man in uniform anti American. Look at the anti-semite people he is putting in positions and in his cabinet.
Isn’t it interesting that to leftist students, those that support Israel are considered “Trumpian”? What does that tell you about where the sides really stand? It’s Trumpian to support Israel? Of course it is. It is because, love him or hate him, Donald Trump was a strong, unapologetic friend of Israel and the Jews. Unlike our reformed friends, he was not “worried” or “nervous” about moving the embassy to Jerusalem or leaving the Iran deal, he was enthusiastic. He chose sides and sided firmly with Israel. The left has rapidly expanded its presence in the Democratic Party and if you want to be a part of that, you better understand they they do not see Israel as David, they see Israel as Goliath. And it’s not just the squad, it is the large progressive wing of the party and BLM who support BDS and are anti-Israel. I’m glad to see you write this letter and that you are feeling uncomfortable with the changing of the party. At least you can see what is happening and aren’t blind to it. Too many of us pretend that nothing has changed and that Joe Biden, and the Democratic Party, are the party of 20 years ago. It’s time to seriously rethink that conclusion. Just as you are doing. So, after you’ve been cancelled by your “enlightened friends”, maybe you’ll rethink things and realize that the old liberal Democratic Party that encouraged freedom of thought is dieing and being replaced by a party of conformity at all cost. And then maybe, just maybe, you, and more of our people, will realize that the world has changed and that conservatives are the party of freedom, placing America and its closest friend, Israel, first.
God bless you Sophia! We need more young people like yourself who are not afraid to speak the truth about what is going on with the Democratic party. i was a democrat most of my life but I didn’t leave the party, the party left me. So I am no longer a part of it. Hope you inspire other students to follow your lead.
I was once a Montgomery County President of the Young Democrats in the 1970’s. I also was also a Democratic committeeman in Cheltenham Township.
I worked for Ed Rendell for Mayor of Philadelphia and for Governor of Pennsylvania. The Democratic Party of today is certainly not the party of before.
The “Squad”, Biden Cabinet members and minorities are
taught to blindly detest Jews and Israel. This is after
many Jews led the struggle for Civil Rights and liberal