Shaare Shamayim Faces Challenge Over Longstanding Signs

2
A Shaare Shamayim sign
The view of one of the two freestanding signs from the street (Courtesy of Congregations of Shaare Shamayim)

Heading down Verree Road, cars pass by the Congregations of Shaare Shamayim every day.

For people unfamiliar with the synagogue or the area, it’s impossible to miss; after all, four signs bear the name of the synagogue, as they have for nearly 40 years.

Two are affixed to a short brick wall. One reads “Congregations of Shaare Shamayim” and the other lists the names of the congregations that have combined to make the Bustleton synagogue what it is.

The larger freestanding sign is blue, double-sided and features a simple white menorah. The smaller freestanding sign directs drivers to parking, with the names of the old congregations in smaller text.

But that may soon change.

Congregants of Shaare Shamayim received in June a notice of several violations related to the signs from the City of Philadelphia’s Department of Licenses and Inspections. L&I completed an inspection of the synagogue’s signage and found them all to be in violation of the city’s zoning laws.

“If the subject sign is not removed or a permit for the subject sign is not obtained, the Department can institute action against you in court to gain compliance,” the letter read.

On Sept. 4, the city refused the congregation’s initial request to keep the signs as they are, so now the synagogue has begun a long and potentially costly appeals process during which it will submit a request for a zoning variance for the signs. The fee to file the request, submitted on Sept. 26, was $300.

“It’s really upsetting,” said Jacques Lurie, the synagogue’s executive director.

Lurie isn’t sure why the signs have become a problem after decades of unchanging size or location. While he stresses that he and the congregation understand that there are rules to be followed that the original sign-erectors may have ignored, the fact that it became an issue in 2019 is vexing.

“To us, it’s a little baffling,” he said.

There are four distinct violations relating to the freestanding sign and the two wall signs.

The view of the wall signs from the street
The view of the wall signs from the street (Photo via Google Street View)

The maximum area of walls signs for residential use is 15 feet; Shaare Shamayim uses 47 feet in its wall signs. The maximum area of freestanding signage allowed for non-residential use is 15 square feet; they synagogue signage measures 134 square feet. The blue freestanding sign is 8 feet, 7 inches, which is 19 inches taller than maximum allowable height for a freestanding sign. And finally, the freestanding signs are required to sit 35 feet back from the street; they are just 5 feet back.

The fact that the violations have come now, after many years, is confusing to Lurie and the congregation. So, too, is another factor: the eye-test precedent set by local churches.

“If you look at comparable religious institutions in the neighborhood, the sign seems to be within reason,” he said.

Another factor in the congregation’s distress is that, in communicating with L&I, Lurie was made aware that the investigation into the signage was preempted by a civilian complaint. Lurie and the congregation don’t know who made the complaint, but they are troubled by it.

Linda Korsin has been a member of the synagogue since 1979, and has lived in the neighborhood for a few years longer than that. The signs predate both her membership and her residence.

“They seem like they’ve been there forever,” she said.

Shaare Shamayim, she said, is well integrated into the larger Bustleton community: Its Cook for a Friend program is popular, it hosts a candidates forum that’s open to the public and it maintains friendly relations with the police. Overall, Korsin said, the synagogue seems to be a “stabilizing force” in the community. That makes the idea of a complaint even more unnerving.

“People are actually feeling a bit hurt,” she said. “Why would anyone want to do us any kind of harm or mischief?”

Lurie agreed. While he’s heard grumbles in the past that there were community members who did not like the sign, the complaint still came as a surprise.

The next step for Shaare Shamayim will be a hearing before the Greater Bustleton Civic League on Dec. 18, when it will plead its case. The Civic League can either give or withhold its stamp of approval before it heads back to the city’s zoning board, where the congregation will make its case on Jan. 29, 2020.

Until then, the congregants will wait — and wonder.

“We’d like to keep our sign that’s been there for 30 or 40 years,” Lurie said. “It’s really a very basic and simple request.”

[email protected]; 215-832-0740

2 COMMENTS

  1. Add Christian to the signs and everything will be Kasher for Philadelphia. It looks similar to any religious institution sign.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here