Letters | Jordan and Liberals

1

Jordan Not Part of Mandate

The op-ed by Lee Bender and Jerome R. Verlin (“‘Two-State Solution’ Isn’t Best for Either Side,” July 11) is premised on the idea that Jordan was once part of the Palestine Mandate, which it was not. The League of Nations awarded Britain the Palestine Mandate in 1922, and it went into effect in 1923. Jordan was not part of the mandate awarded to Britain, though, for eight months in 1920-’21, Jordan was temporarily included in Palestine.

Bender and Verlin use this false claim (that Jordan is Palestine) to make the case that Jordan should be the Palestinian state while the West Bank and the Gaza Strip become a part of Israel. But there is reason to doubt that the Palestinians, Jordanians or Israelis would be comfortable with that outcome.

Palestinians aspire to have a state of their own in the West Bank and Gaza (if not beyond), while Jordan has explicitly said that Jordan is not Palestine. Thus, the chance of Jordan becoming the Palestinian state is hardly a realistic scenario.

Andrew Kofsky, intern, Foreign Policy Research Institute | Philadelphia

Liberals Excluded Jews, Too

It was good of Marc Stier to concede that President Donald Trump is not yet Hitler (“Why We Remember,” July 4). But I wonder if he would have said that about previous presidents who excluded Jews from entering the United States when these Jews were in much more dire, life-threatening situations than are the present-day migrants at the southern border.

I am talking about Franklin D. Roosevelt, whose administration kept out hundreds of thousands of Jewish refugees who could have been saved if his administration had opened the doors to these refugees. In fact, Germany had a large immigration quota, but FDR’s State Department did not let it be filled even in the critical years of the 1930s. Polish Jews had even less luck than German Jews in finding refuge in the USA.

More recently, President Barack Obama, an admirer of FDR, pressured the government of Israel not to let Jews move across the 1949 armistice line in order to reside in what is called the West Bank or Judea and Samaria. Thereby Obama denied the right of Jews to live in that area, a right recognized in international law by the League of Nations.

When it comes to excluding people from entering a certain territory, Stier might voice a complaint against leaders of liberal and progressive movements in the USA who thought that it was perfectly okay to exclude Jews.

Elliott Green | Jerusalem

1 COMMENT

  1. Andrew Kofsky in his letter “Jordan not part of Mandate” incorrectly claims that “Jordan was not part of the mandate awarded to Britain, though, for eight months in 1920-’21, Jordan was temporarily included in Palestine.”

    Jordan remained part of the Mandate until 1946 when it was granted independence by Great Britain.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here