Hillel Already Is an Open Forum


In advance of the ‘Open Hillel’ conference, Hillel International’s CEO explains why pluralism and support for Israel are not contradictions.

Once again the love affair between the Jewish people and higher education is back in full bloom. The start of a new school year — and the Jewish new year — marked the beginning of robust programming for Jewish college students across the globe.
As students dig into their studies, the events in Israel and Gaza this past summer are a hot topic on many campuses. In response, Hillel International, the largest Jewish student organization in the world, is drawing on its expertise to promote deep and thoughtful discussion. Hillel is sponsoring a broad range of programs to help students understand the issues and how they will affect Israel and its neighbors in the future.
Hillel professionals have heard presentations from both Israeli diplomats and elected officials. Hillel student leaders have organized interfaith gatherings and intercultural dialogues. Hillel educators have offered seminars and discussions for students to learn about contemporary Israeli society and culture, to reflect on their own relationships with Israel and to develop skills as dialogue facilitators.
Hillel students have also modeled what respectful discourse looks like. For example, at Cooper Union Hillel in New York City, students countered an effort to boycott a speech by the leader of the Palestinian Authority, Mahmoud Abbas, and encouraged Jewish students to attend and listen respectfully, which they did.
What all these activities have in common is they welcome and include students of all backgrounds and political positions  who have a wide array of relationships with their Jewish identities and with Israel. They do so in an environment that is intellectually rigorous, respectful of difference and committed to honest conversation.
Hillel is among the most religiously, intellectually, culturally and politically pluralistic organizations in the Jewish world — a testament to both the diversity of Jewish experience and of college campuses we serve.
Inclusivity and broad-mindedness are part of our core values. All students are always welcome at Hillel. And these values guide all of our work. That work includes listening to all student voices, including those of the activists behind the “Open Hillel” campaign and other campus groups.
At the same time, Hillel is deeply dedicated to Israel. From the tens of thousands we’ve led on Taglit-Birthright Israel trips, to the nearly 100 Israelis who serve as Israel Fellows on our campuses, to the many efforts of our professionals to engage and educate students, Israel is a vital part of our mission.
For some, those simultaneous commitments to openness and pluralism as well as to passionate support of Israel may seem contradictory. For Hillel, there is no contradiction. Our Standards for Partnership, which were developed in close consultation with local Hillels, are designed to ensure  these commitments to openness and pluralism and to Israel. Hillel will not partner with organizations that espouse anti-Semitism, apply a double standard to Israel, spout racism or promote Islamophobia. Such viewpoints do not represent the values of Hillel International or of most Jewish students and professionals.
Hillel’s programming decisions are made by local student leaders, professionals and lay leaders dedicated to engaging the largest number of students in Jewish life on their campuses. These leaders are guided by their knowledge of the local environment and by Hillel’s vision of encouraging students to build an enduring commitment to Jewish life, learning and Israel.
This past weekend, activists who created the “Open Hillel” campaign met at Harvard University. The campaign calls on Hillel to eliminate its Standards of Partnership in order to provide a platform for organi­zations that promote the boycott, divest­ment and sanctions movement, known as BDS, and other anti-Israel activities.
I recently met with some leaders of this campaign and listened to their concerns. They assured me that they consider themselves a part of Hillel. I reiterated to them that every student is welcome at Hillel regardless of his or her personal views on Israel or any other topic in Jewish life.
At the same time, Hillel International stands by its Standards of Partnership. We work every day to help students find their connection to the Jewish people and live the Jewish values that make this a better world for all people. As we grow, Hillel will continue to hold firm to the values that define the Jewish community worldwide — peoplehood, nationhood and faith in the future.
Eric Fingerhut is the president and CEO of Hillel International.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here